Skip to main content

The American War of Independence vs. The French Revolution

It is no great secret that I am obsessed with the French Revolution. It may not be as well known, however, that I consider it to be the most revolutionary event in the history of democracy. Yes, that is right...THE most. Even more so than the American War of Independence. Upon sharing this notion, many people are highly incensed and usually quip something to the effect of, "Well, if it wasn't for America, France would still be under German control!" (To which I typically respond, "Yes, but if it wasn't for France, America would still be under British control...") 

Then, it is mere seconds until the French jokes commence. You know, ones like: What color is the French battle flag? White. And, how can you tell the French Army? They're the ones with the sunburned armpits. Really.

I never really have the opportunity to offer any rationale to my seemingly unpatriotic and ludicrous statement. So, please indulge me a moment and let me explain...

My explanation, in its most basic form, is in the blog title: The American War of Independence vs. The French Revolution. America fought a war to become independent. France embarked on a revolution to change. We all know that America was a British colony that eventually became fed up with "taxation without representation," declared its independence from England, and fought a long and agonizing war but in the end democracy prevailed and a new nation was born. (how's that for succinct?!)  Not so in France.

The difference here is that, through the French Revolution, France toppled and CHANGED a government that had been in existence for over a thousand years (aptly known as l'ancien régime, or ancient regime). And although things weren't great in the American colonies (no one likes to be taxed and unrepresented), colonists could at least own land and buy a loaf of bread at a reasonable price (unlike in France where the average citizen could not own land and there was a famine so severe that people were dying...all whilst Marie Antoinette ate her cake*) 

Prior to the start of the French Revolution, traces of feudalism remained and the infamous socioeconomic hierarchy known as "The Three Estates" dictated power and privilege. The First Estate, made up predominately of the religious orders, and the Second Estate, made up of the nobility, held the real power. They were the ones with money, connections (especially to the Big Guy), rights, titles, and political power. The Third Estate was made up of everyone who wasn't a titled noble or church official. When voting would occur at the Estates General, each Estate was given one vote. Now, before you go thinking that this sounds more fair than what American colonists had, just read on...

Here was the problem with that structure. The First & Second Estates (Church & nobles) ALWAYS sided together. So, their voting block rendered the Third Estate's vote lone and useless. When you consider that the First & Second Estates made up only 3% of the population of France (in case you're not a math whiz, that meant that the Third Estate made up 97% of the population), the better part of France had no true representation.

But, you may ask, what about the taxation part? Well, let's just say that France had a looonng tradition of taxing most those with the least. In addition to taxes, there were mandatory tithes to the Church. So, while the poorest part of the population carried the burden of society, the richest carried the burden of partying like it was 1799. So, much like early Americans, the French had been living for hundreds of years under the premise of taxation without representation.

There were other long and short term causes of the French Revolution, but when you figure that the average French citizen had no rights, no liberties, no land, and no vote, things sound bad. When you factor in overtaxed, over-tithed and underpaid, things go from bad to worse. Throw in the hunger factor, and no wonder the French were so grouchy. 

Disclaimer for the following paragraph: I am not condoning one sort of violence over another or minimizing the losses of early American life. I'm just illustrating my point, so do not be offended. If you are offended, well, just deal with it. I plead the First... 

So what is the difference between a "war of independence"  and a "revolution?" The key lies in the means by which the end is achieved. When America began its quest for independence, yes, there was bloodshed. No loss of life is ever ideal, but it was within the confines of civil, upright, good ole European-style warfare (a.k.a. line up in two rows facing each other and shoot). Not so in France. 

In France, it was like extreme warfare hyped up on Red Bull and crack. In fact, I think that on Bastille Day, the saying "all hell broke loose" was born. We thought tarring and feathering Loyalists was Chuck Norris-esque? Try hacking off heads with fish knives, putting the detached head on a pike and parading it around town. That, mes amis, is extreme. 

The pinnacle of violence was of course, the guillotine. And perhaps there are no two victims better known than the King and Queen of France themselves, Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette.  With the monarchy overthrown and dead (apparently there was no way other countries could help reinstate headless royal corpses...) the door was wide open for a completely new government. The last time I checked, although despised, George III kept his head...and the English monarchy remained in tact. 

Now, don't get me wrong. I am not discrediting or minimizing the importance of our Founding Fathers or those who fought for independence. As a matter of fact, I am downright grateful for what they did (although I wish we could all still speak with British accents - they do sound so much better!) It's just if I was ranking the most important events in history, I would rank the French Revolution above the American War of Independence. Both ultimately resulted in democracy. However, only one, in its own extreme fashion, reversed over a thousand years of history and inequality and forged a new republic out of an ancien régime and indelibly defined the word REVOLUTION.

*A reference to the myth that, when told about the starving population, Marie Antoinette replied, "Let them eat cake." She never said it...just nasty propaganda that lives on today.
Follow on Bloglovin


Anonymous said…
This is quite interesting. I look forward to your next posts.
Anonymous said…
I agree that the French revolution was "revolutionary" than the American War of Independence. I'm still not sure I would call it the most important event in History tho...
Americans as a whole need to get out the habit of holding up our system as the pinnacle of democratic achievement. There is much to be said for a British System that has evolved "organically" and, as such is not littered with elements of a by-gone age, (the right to bear arms springs to mind!!)The relationship of the executive, judiciary and Congress as laid out in the Consitution leads to stagnated gridlock, where often the only way a bill is passed is through pork-barrell spending!
Any how interesting comments!!

Popular posts from this blog

Les Femmes Tondues

It is no great secret that some French collaborated during the Nazi Occupation of France. Some did it for less than admirable reasons, such as political gain, anti-Semitism, or true fascist ideology. Other people were frightened and saw no end to the Occupation, while some were motivated simply by the desire to survive. Many women who collaborated fall into the latter category. Food, clothes, and fuel (among other items) were scarce during the Occupation. Nearly everything needed to sustain life was rationed, and much of France's food and other necessary commodities were shipped to Germany. One way to ensure warmth and a full belly was by making nice with a German soldier. 
In a desperate attempt to survive, some French women took on German soldiers as lovers. It return, the soldier ensured the woman's basic needs were met. Not all women had affairs for material gain - some simply slept with German soldiers because they were lonely. Either way, these sexual liaisons produced man…

La Rafle du Vel d’Hiv (The Vel d’Hiv Round Up)

Photo Source: 1st Art Gallery
Every Holocaust survivor – every ghost of those who did not survive - has a story to tell. Each story is unique, yet equally tragic. Some we have heard more than once, while others lay silent, buried in the dusty pages of a nation’s shame…
Occupation and Anti-Semitism 14 June 1942 marked the two-year anniversary of the Nazi occupation of Paris. By this point, many French had joined the Résistance, while others felt it in their best interest to collaborate with the Nazi regime. Many Jews had fled France, and those who remained behind lived in chronic fear. The Jewish Decrees (France's version of the Nuremberg Laws) saw the Jews of Paris stripped of their livelihoods, property, and rights. As in other occupied areas of Europe, the French Jews were required to wear the yellow stars of David. Inscribed with a single word in the center, Juif (Jew), the badges had to be sewn neatly on the left side of the chest. Failure to do so could land a person in jail – o…

A Little Zazou ~ Pour Vous

Sorry Disney fans, but I am not talking about Simba's little feathered hornbill friend in the Lion King (that's spelled Zazu anyway). No, I am talking about the Zazou Jazz Era that began in Interwar Paris and les zazous who, in their own way, defied Vichy and the Nazis when they occupied France during the Second World War. 
Thanks to my ADD that always manages to kick in when I am supposed to be doing serious research, I stumbled upon the concept of zazou when I was - you guessed it - researching for my Master's thesis on the French Resistance last year. 
While I was disappointed that I could not use this newfound knowledge in my thesis, all was not lost. This detour introduced me not only to the fascinating history of les zazous, but some really remarkable Manouche Jazz (a.k.a. Gypsy Swing Jazz) that I knew would some day make a great blog. Lucky you, mes chers, that day is today!
What the Heck IS Zazou? Zazou describes a style of jazz as well as a group of people. Les zazous